This is a real Forensic Opinion from a live engagement, with every client-identifying detail removed. The figures are illustrative of a redacted account spending roughly $40,000 a month. It shows exactly what lands on your desk: one defensible number, the reconciliation behind it, every finding rated and evidenced, and the parts that came back clean.
An audit from someone who wants to manage your account has an agenda built into it. This one structurally cannot. Every Opinion opens with the same four sworn clauses.
I am paid a fixed fee, in full, before any findings are delivered.
My fee is not contingent on what I find. A Clean Bill is a valid, paid result.
I do not offer, and will not be retained for, implementation or managed services on this account.
I read the numbers you already have. Nothing is installed and nothing in your account is changed.
Every figure carries its denominator. Every finding names one line you can verify in your own account in fifteen minutes, without trusting a word of this report. What could not be assessed is stated plainly, and the healthy parts are given a Clean Bill.
One fixed severity scale, from P0 down to a Clean Bill. Each finding is measured to the dollar in annual terms, cross-checked three independent ways, and tied to a numbered exhibit in the evidence dossier.
| # | Area | Finding | Severity | Conf. | Annual |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Distribution | Terms below breakeven since the Feb-02 portfolio bid-strategy change · Exhibit 03 | P0 | HIGH | $128k |
| 02 | Measurement | Phantom view-through conversions inflating reported revenue · Exhibit 05 | P0 | HIGH | $74k |
| 03 | Incentive | Brand terms reharvesting clicks that would convert for free · Exhibit 06 | P1 | MED | $61k |
| 04 | Automation | Target ROAS set on revenue, not net margin · Exhibit 08 | P1 | MED | $49k |
| 05 | Offline sales | Back-end CRM revenue not connected during the read (2 line items) · Exhibit 11 | Not assessable | n/a | n/a |
| 06 | Geo & pacing | Budget delivery and geo split healthy across the window · Exhibit 12 | Clean bill | PASS | $0 |
Severity scale: P0 bleeding now · P1 material · Not assessable named, never guessed · Clean Bill a valid result. Annual figures are the illustrative twelve-month impact on this redacted account.
On February 2, a portfolio bid strategy was applied across the account's non-brand campaigns. The strategy optimized to reported conversion value, not to net margin. Over the following weeks, spend concentrated onto a tier of search terms whose contribution margin, once cost of goods was applied, was already negative. The dashboard never flagged it, because at the revenue line those terms still "converted."
Illustrative and redacted. Your engagement reports only what your own data substantiates.
A figure survives into this Opinion only if three independent sources agree: what you spent, what the platform reported, and what your back-end actually booked. The gap between reported and reconciled is where confidence is lost, and where the normalized ROAS is set.
| Source | Basis | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Ad spend | Billing, verified | $480k |
| Platform-reported conversion value | Google Ads, reported | $2.21M |
| Back-end reconciled revenue | CRM + payments | $1.15M |
| Unreconciled, reported over back-end | Inflation | $1.06M |
The account is still profitable at 2.4x. The point is that 4.6x is the number steering the bidding, and it is buying volume the back-end never receives. The recoverable margin sits inside that gap.
Each fix is scored by dollars returned per hour of work, so the largest recoverable margin comes back first. You hand this to your team or your agency, or walk it with me in an optional session. I never touch the account.
Of the $312,000 identified, roughly $273,000 is recoverable inside the current strategy without new budget or new creative. The remainder depends on merchandising and offline capture decisions outside the account, which is why it is named separately rather than promised.
An audit chasing a retainer never writes this page. Naming what is healthy is what separates a forensic read from a sales document.
A Clean Bill is a valid, paid result. Most owners have never been handed one.
For Google Ads accounts spending $25,000+/mo. By application, a limited number of engagements each month. One account, one fixed fee, one signed verdict, even if the verdict is that you are clean.
thedoctorads.com · igor@thedoctorads.com